Have you tried Cabot's 3 year cheddar? If you fancy a strapping, robust, and brawny cheddar this is your cheese! It's really wonderful with wine or whatever you'd like to eat it with or melt it on. I buy mine in 2 lb. bricks at Costo (pic above). approx $12 for the brick is a real bargain. It puts to shame some cheddars twice that price.